Home About Archives Contributors Contact
  November 2009
 
Beatle Mania
Megan Marshall
 

The Beatles are timeless. Their music has been popular for over twenty years,
and their albums are still selling like hot cakes. Recently,
all of the Beatles' albums were re-released and re-issued and remastered.
Also released were box sets of mono recordings and stereo recordings.
The trouble lies in that many do not know the difference between mono
and stereo recordings.

Mono is the short form for monaural or monophonic sound,
and is a single-channel recording often with only one microphone or speaker
fed into one channel. However there were two types of mono recordings.
The first being one track recorded as one channel. The other being two tracks
(ie vocals and instruments) being streamed and recorded together
as a singular channel. This recording method was popular and used in the early
1900s for means of AM radios and vinyl pressings. It was a simple, inexpensive
method to record, however it created a more dense, concentrated sound.
The Beatles' first album, Please Please Me, was one of the first compact
discs to be released in mono. The first 10 albums released by the Beatles were
recorded in mono, only to be later re-issued and remastered in stereo formatting.
Yellow Submarine was the last album to be released in mono in 1969.
The demise of mono came in the early 1950s when stereophonic technology
took over and became more common.

 
 
Stereophonic (or stereo) recording is the reproduction of sound using
two or more independent sound tracks (ie vocals, harmony vocals, instruments)
to recreate a sound similar to hearing something in person - the sound seemingly
coming from all directions, not just in one direct stream. By all means, stereo
recording is much more diverse, intricate and complex than merely one-track
recording. The Beatles' first stereo album was Abbey Road in 1969, and
subsequently the remainder of their albums were recorded as such.

In determining the differences between mono and stereo recordings,
it appears evident that stereo would be the better purchase, right? Maybe.
To this day, and in lieu of the new formatted Beatles releases, there remains
strong opposition over which is the 'better' sound and ultimately, the 'better' buy.
Many defend mono by stating that these ten albums were originally recorded
in mono, therefore this is the way they should be heard.

Links:
Fieldstone Gardens
Leo Del Pasqua
Beatle Mania
Megan Marshall
Lonely Monarch
Hugh Petrie
Carrying Signs
Chris Hinsperger 
The Essential Question
Oscar Bearinger
A Warm Embrace
Laurie Stephenson
The Killaloe Story
Lisa Hooker 
'No Angel' Release
Dean Batstone

Meanwhile others claim that the remastering of mono into stereo
offers a more full bodied, clear sound.

Mono is raw and pure, whereas stereo is tampered with and altered.
Mono is dull, whereas stereo is vibrant. There are varying degrees of support
for and against both methods of recording. My personal opinion is that the mono
box set is tailored more so towards collectors and connoisseurs of musical history.
It is certainly a wonderful collection of the early Beatles, in the original recording
format. However, for the average listener and/or consumer, the stereo box is
more practical. The customer obtains every Beatles album in one delightful package.
Regardless of whether you prefer mono or stereo, the fact is that the demand
for Beatles' music is very much alive and thriving. The Beatles have transcended
the rocky transitions from vinyl to 8 track to cassette to compact discs, and
are still top sellers to this day. Though I cannot, with a clear conscience,
rationalize that the Beatles are "bigger than Jesus" (John Lennon, 1966),
I can concede that perhaps the two were on the same team - continually
encouraging the world to 'come together', be it through music or religion.
Something tells me neither will be forgotten in the next 50 years.




"One thing I can tell you is you got to be free
Come together right now over me
..."

[Abbey Road]



Home About Archives Contributors Contact
deesigns